Euverlèk:Kirchröadsj: Versjèl tösje versies

Verwijderde inhoud Toegevoegde inhoud
Sol505000 (Euverlèk | biedrages)
Geen bewerkingssamenvatting
Sol505000 (Euverlèk | biedrages)
Geen bewerkingssamenvatting
Tekslien 6:
:::::Gewoen zuver praktisch: De mieste lui oet Kèrkraoj höbbe vas gein idee wat "Ripuarisch" is en allemaol neume ze hun taol "Limbörgs". Daorum, en um de op 't Nederlands (en neet op 't Duits) gebaseerde spèlling, laote v'r ze hei touw. Op de Ripuarische Wikipedia zien ze nörges. [[Gebroeker:Steinbach|𐏂𐎫𐎹𐎴𐎲𐎧]] <small>Op nao de 10.000!</small> 28 nov 2009 18:46 (CET)
:::::: De meeste mensen in Keulen, Aken of Bonn hebben echter ook geen idee wat "Ripuarisch" is. Dat is een uitsluitend taalwetenschappelijk begrip dat nergens inheems is.
:Either way it is unreasonable to have articles in Kerkraads split between two Wikipedias. It's not even that speakers of the Kerkrade dialect consider their dialect to be a separate language, it's that they are ''unaware'' of the existence of Ripuarian. It is precisely for this reason that articles in Kerkraads should be moved to the Kölsch (Ripuarian) Wikipedia, and so should articles in other dialects ([[Bóchezer]], [[Brókkelzer]], [[Völzer]] and [[Jömelejer]], if articles in the last one aren't there already), that are classified as Ripuarian by linguists. What we have now is, in my opinion, unacceptable. Would you accept articles in Brabantian here? What about Low Saxon? According to [https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Meuse-Rhenish-nl.png this map], Limburgish is spoken in a small southeastern part of Noord Brabant. If a Brabantian WP was ever created (or if it already has, I dunno), would it be acceptable for speakers of those dialects to submit articles written in their dialect to that Wikipedia, rather than here?
:However you choose to handle this situation, having articles written in one and the same language variety (the Kerkrade dialect of Ripuarian) split over two Wikipedias is the worst possible solution. It's not even that speakers of Kerkraads consider it to be a separate language (so that the situation is unlike Serbo-Croatian), it's that they're unaware of the correct linguistic classification. [[Gebroeker:Sol505000|Sol505000]] ([[Euverlèk gebroeker:Sol505000|euverlègk]]) 31 okt 2020 03:49 (CET)
 
Aafkomstig van Wikipedia, de Vriej Encyclopedie. "https://li.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euverlèk:Kirchröadsj"
Terugkeren naar de pagina "Kirchröadsj".